Monday, March 16, 2009
Review of In His Own Write by John Lennon
What I think I most like about it is the fact that the reader really has to apply his or her own meaning to the text. The text itself is very engaging and filled with humor, but meaning has to be found by the reader, and one reader's interpretation may be incredibly different from another's. In fact, I found myself applying multiple different meanings to the same piece.
One thing I noticed, being a bit (or maybe more than a bit) of a Lennon aficionado is his references to the grotesque (including a talking bump on a man's head) and the disabled (including a girl in a wheelchair). Through a lot of my biographical reading of Lennon, it has been noted that Lennon was always fascinated with these differences in humankind. Lennon often did routines where he would imitate mentally challenged individuals, which most would find off-putting today, but were a part of Lennon's sense of humor. This fascination is evident in In His Own Write.
The line drawings are great as always and very comical. His drawing are mostly so elementary, but somehow, I have never seen anything quite like them. I do think that Lennon's later line drawings are better, but the ones in the book are very identifiable as Lennon.
I think some of my favorite pieces are the poems, my favorite piece in the book being "I Sat Belonely." I highly recommend the book to anyone. It only takes about an hour to read, but it is definitely worth rereading many times. I think that I will find something new every time I read it for the rest of my life (something I believe true of all of Lennon's writings).
Review of The Dharma Bums by Jack Kerouac
The Dharma Bumsis an incredibly relaxing read. While I was reading the book, I wanted nothing more than to lay in the grass under a shade tree in the mild spring weather that has sporadically been gracing Amarillo of late (perhaps in the lotus position). I never actually succumbed to my urges, but it was tempting. The tone of the book is reflective of the Zen Buddhismthat Ray Smith (Kerouac's semi-autobiographic character) practices. One does gather the impression that many of the characters, including Ray and Japhy, know very little about the actual practice of Buddhism, and while their path is a spiritual one, it is constantly contradicted by the hedonistic lifestyle of drugs, alcohol, and free love practiced by the novel's participants. In fact, the juxtaposition of the two ideals seems to be Kerouac trying to find a balance between the two seemingly contradictory lifestyles. There are even moments where, in retrospect, Kerouac seems to be poking fun at some of his beliefs that he had at the actual time events took place in the novel (since they are most biographical and Kerouac wrote it retrospectively).
One of the things that truly impacted my reading was the romanticism found in the book. Kerouac returns to a worship of nature, not seen since the early 20th century, but what makes it so incredibly odd is the other events that Kerouac romanticizes so greatly, all generally relating to being a poor, unmaterialistic bum. It wouldn't be a Kerouac novel without traversing the country with an upheld thumb, which Ray does from California to North Carolina, back again and from California north to Washington state. Ray is introduced to nature by Japhy Ryder (thought to be real life beat poet Gary Snyder). This hitchhiking, living with only a pack and a sleeping bag on one's back, and living a materially simplistic lifestyle is praised above all else in the novel.
Having done a little research on the historic basis for the novel, I noticed that most critics pay a lot of attention to what were historically the Six Gallery reading where Ginsberg (Alvah Goldbook in the novel) recited "Howl" ("Wail" in the novel). Kerouac refused to read at the reading, most likely due to his level of intoxication, but most historians agree that Kerouac delivers a lucid and fairly accurate recollection of events.
Unlike On the Roadthe protagonist (Kerouac's representative) has no serious romantic interest. In fact, it almost seems that if there is a romantic interest for Ray, it is Japhy Ryder. Now while, it is made clear that their relationship is platonic (Kerouac includes just enough reference to the opposite sex to let the reader know that he is decidedly heterosexual), Smith constantly thinks of Japhy when he is away from him ("What would Japhy think," "I can't wait to tell Japhy something-or-other," etc.). Japhy represents what Ray aspires to be. From the reader's perspective, Japhy seems no more sane than Ray. In fact, he seems less so at points. Ray idealizes Japhy as someone who has life all figured out, but Japhy is constantly contradicting himself and changing his mind. For example, when Ray returns to California, Japhy does not want to hear Ray's musings, saying that words are meaningless, but Japhy himself engages in constant talking, talking about nothing. In another instance, Japhy accuses Ray of drinking too much (which I am sure is true, Ray being the real Kerouac and all), but later the very same day, Japhy returns from a lecture on Buddhism completely sauced and admits that he was wrong about drinking to Ray.
I believe that two things had to happen for postmodernism to come into being, the first being the complete abandonment in the faith of mankind seen in early sci-fi novels like 1984, Fahrenheit 451, and Brave New World. The second thing that had to happen was the beats who changed completely conceptions of morality and romanticism (a very twisted romanticism). The beats also had to contribute their east-meets-west ideals, making postmodernism a truly world event.
I find this post truly rambling, but in lieu of it being about a beat novel, editing is completely out of the question. I recommend this book to anyone and everyone who can read and has a brain in their head (even though you should really read On the Road first).
Thursday, March 5, 2009
Review of Ben Kweller's Changing Horses
![]() | For People Who Like: Bright Eyes, Cub Country, Fountains of Wayne songs that aren't singles Genre: Alt Country Best 3 Songs: 1. "Old Hat" 2. "Hurtin' You" 3. "On Her Own" Worst 3 Songs: 1. "Things I Like to Do" 2. "Fight" 3. "Wantin' Her Again" Overall Grade: C+ |
Guess who got a steel guitar for Christmas this year and wants to share it with everyone: Ben Kweller, that's who. One of my friends has referred to Ben Kweller as Weezer without the suck. This is a completely different Kweller, though. It's his shot at a country album. I like B.K., but I have to say, don't quit your day job. At least it is still better than Weezer.
The first thing any decent album needs is a good first song, which Kweller doesn't deliver. "Gypsy Rose" is almost a complete throwaway. I almost have forgotten the song while I am listening to it. It is also the strangest song on the album and the least Kweller-like. His vocals generally sound like himself throughout most of the songs, but not in "Gypsy Rose." It really alienates Kweller fans (like myself) who have picked up the album. Ben may be trying to recruit some new fans, but he will ultimately fail because he just doesn't do country well enough to recruit people who actually like country (like not myself).
It seems like so much of the time that the songs use steel guitar to no purpose whatsoever. I believe that all but two songs make use of a steel guitar. It often even detracts from some songs, especially "Sawdust Man," which would be a better song without steel guitar altogether. Many of the lyrics come off as cliche country and bluegrass lyrics. I would write it off to satire, but I don't understand why the whole album isn't satirical in that case. In "Fight" Kweller talks over the guitar solo with cliches, and I really do believe it to be mocking of country and bluegrass music, because I almost laugh out loud when I hear that part. I am not sure any of it is intended as satire, but it often comes off that way.
Lyrically, the album really struggles to find Kweller's normal audience and is really kind of all over the place. The worst song lyrically is "Things I Like to Do," but is closely followed by "Fight," which actually contains a positive message to "Fight 'til your dying day," but I somehow think that Kweller's audience will have trouble relating to a trucker, which is what the song is about.
Because of the similar instrumentation in so many of the songs, they start to blend into each other, taking special not of "Wantin' Her Again" running immediately into "Things I Like to Do." Neither song should have ever been recorded, but, Ben, couldn't you have at least spared us from hearing one of those?
The album isn't all bad though. Generally, the ballads are decent to good and when the song features piano (with or without steel guitar), the song turns out better. The songs are all interesting to hear Kweller singing them, because it is a strange combination because he still sounds like himself most of the time.
"Old Hat" is probably my favorite song on the album. It is the most Kweller-like, and while it maintains a country tinge, I don't think it would be that out of place on a normal B.K. album. The song is good lyrically, though referring to oneself as an "old hat" to put on a girl's "pretty head" is odd for B.K. This song is probably my favorite because it is the perfect combination of piano and steel guitar. The steel guitar solo in the bridge is actually really atypical, and that makes it interesting.
My other two favorites are "Hurtin' You" and "On Her Own." In "Hurtin' You," I can really relate to the subject of helplessness that the lyrics portray. I also really enjoy the vocals in the bridge-- when Ben hits those high notes, he just gets a lot more raw. Once again, this is a slower piano song, so it must be better. "On Her Own" is empowering to women, and I have a special respect for a male artist that conveys this message-- that a woman can do it on her own. The harmonies in the chorus are really not typical for the song, and definitely add a little something, and guess what? This song once again features the piano.
I will make honorable mention of one other song: "Homeward Bound." The song is very hymn-like and could in the future usurp one of my current top three. And this song is the best choice for the last song on the album, so I have to complement the album organization there.
Overall the album lacks flow and just comes off a little strange. It will probably be an album that I have to skip around on, which means I will listen to it on the mp3 player and not a lot in the car, but generally, I hate albums that I have to skip songs on, so it will most likely get only a moderate amount of listening. I look forward to Ben's next real album. I am thinking this was a one-time experiment and B.K. with be back with some great pop-rock in the future. To all Kweller fans: you can probably skip out on this one.
Wednesday, March 4, 2009
Review of Rant by Chuck Palahniuk
First of all, I enjoyed the narrative style of the novel. It is a story told through mock interview snippets of more than fifty characters, yet somehow it forms a complete and cohesive story, while still maintaining some mystery about the enigmatic characters. Certainly, there are points where the narrators contradict each other, but it doesn't take away from the actual storyline. The disagreement is, of course, necessary for verisimilitude.
The story focuses on Rant Casey, patient number one in the current rabies epidemic that is overrunning some alternate reality (most likely a reality brought into existence by the main character himself). Rant actually doesn't narrate any of his own story, except in a flashback in which he calls into a radio broadcast and the broadcast is transcribed for the reader. The story is winding and reveals many surprises. There are some events that Palahniuk chooses to reveal early in the novel to throw the reader off-balance, suspecting foul play of certain characters, but not knowing exactly what these devious characters are up to. Rant attains a god-like status, or maybe even an actual god status. And yes, there is certainly something very Christ-like about the protagonist.
Palahniuk, as usual, treats the writers in all his readers to a workshop in unreliable narration. No character is completely trustworthy. However, the person who should be the most trustworthy in the entire story in my opinion, Irene Casey (Rant's mother), is the least reliable-- not because she is a liar, but because of her undying naivety that borders on idiocy.
There is also a great dichotomy between day and night. The characters live in a world where they are only allowed out in public for half of the day. Palahniuk does make everything night and day, not to say that everything is black and white, but the divide between the daytimers and the nighttimers is fixed and implacable. In this world many of the nighttimers participate in "Party Crashing," which is basically a huge public game of demolition derby with a very fixed set of rules. As a reader, I often doubted the sanity of the Party Crashers, but in the end, I believe them to be the sane ones. Palahniuk made me question what sanity really is. Rant becomes a philosopher in death, making us doubt what is a "correct" perception of the world. Over the radio, Rant says, "What if reality is nothing but some disease?" He is also later quoted as saying, "The future you have tomorrow won't be the same future you had yesterday."
That brings me to the idea of the past and history to which Palahniuk alludes. The past is always changing (even when time travelling isn't involved). It is rewritten and reconceived in the minds of those witnessed history as it happened. The past, present, and future merge into one in Rant. Rant's future is his past and his past is his future in many ways.
Another subject that the book deals with is the idea of paternity and who we are because of our fathers. Rant battles this question his entire life, having had an encounter with a passerby in his youth who tells him that he is his true father, not the father who Rant has known his whole life. Rant seeks out his true father, much in the way of a lost man trying to find himself. The thing is Rant already established in his own person.
I think the thing that really baffles me is that, as readers, we are told contradicting stories throughout the entire novel, but in the end everything we are told could be true (except probably for Irene Casey's narration). I think maybe that is where Palahniuk started in his head before starting to write the book-- making seeming lies into truths through the revelation of very intriguing plot twists.
I hope that I haven't given away too much in my review. I tried to be cryptic. It is just a hard book to talk about without revealing a few things (though none of the great revelations are mentioned here). I really enjoyed Palahniuk, as usual. It is a very easy read. I still think that Diary is my favorite Chuck Palahniuk, but this does come in a close second, beating out Lullaby by a hair. It is a book that will keep me thinking for some time to come.
Thursday, February 19, 2009
Green Green Goblins
Green Green Goblins
“The only people for me are the mad ones, the ones who are mad to live, mad to talk, mad to be saved, desirous of everything at the same time, the ones who never yawn or say a commonplace thing, but burn, burn, burn, like fabulous Roman candles exploding like spiders across the stars.” (Jack Kerouac, On the Road)
* * *
I awoke at the crowing of a truck’s airhorn.
The cars whistled by overhead, making a thu-thunk sound as they passed over the lines of dried tar on the bridge. I uncurled myself from the fetal position. Even Florida gets a little cold in January. I’d made the cross country journey from Oregon just in time to escape the wet and cold winter in Portland. It was already cold in September when I passed through Texas, where they play nothing but horrible cowboy music. I finally made it to Florida in October and had a few months to bask in the warm Indian summer sun.
I stretched out on the underpass embankment, trying to loose the frigid stiffness from my bones. The sun was just coming up. Must have been about half past seven. I was tired, but I didn’t yawn. I scooted down the embankment until there was enough room for me to stand. I reached up and grasped my hands over my head—my body shivered, but I didn’t yawn.
I reached into my pockets to see what state I was in for the day: two nickels and two pennies. Twelve cents. Twelve fucking cents. I was starving, but breakfast was obviously going to have to wait. At least I had eaten lunch yesterday. I could make it until dinner today if I had to.
Halfway down the embankment I remembered the book. My one possession. The only thing that I needed in the world besides the warm Florida climate and a meal every once in a while. I had tucked the book in the crevice between the bridge embankment and the underside of the road the night before. I pulled the book out from my secret hiding spot and dusted it off, or rather dusted off the Ziploc bag that contained the book. The book was in remarkably good shape considering that it was over sixty years old, and I had read it in more than a hundred times: from Seattle, to Portland, and on my cross-country journey to sunny Miami Beach. It was the only thing I still had from Seattle, from my old life. It was the only thing that I wanted to remember.
I made my way down to the intersection. The cardboard sign I had made yesterday was still there: “Homeless Hungry Trying to Get Home” the sign read. I had no intention of leaving Miami. The weather is warm enough that I could live outdoors year-round. I was looking forward to the spring, when I could go and sleep on the sandy beach at night.
Having removed the book from the plastic bag and put the bag in my pocket, I assumed my position, the sign in my left hand, and in my right, the book, making sure not to crack the spine. The book was still relatively well-bound, and I wanted to keep it that way. I read, only glancing up to see if anyone would give me money or food during the red lights. Most people tried as hard as they could not to make eye contact. The car people don’t want to take a look at how bad they think life can be. I don’t shower very often and I don’t even know that I would remember how to shave.
It must have been around ten in the morning when I heard a woman’s voice.
“Hey, buddy.” I looked around and couldn’t find who was calling to me for a moment. I then spotted a few fingers waving out of the tinted windows of a Mercedes. “Sir,” the voice called again. I started over to the car. The fingers retracted inside the luxury shell and a sandwich in a plastic bag soon appeared in place of the fingers. I was now next to the door.
“I thought you looked hungry, and I thought you might like a sandwich.”
I snatched the sandwich from the window. I could see the woman’s peroxide blonde hair and Dior sunglasses, but little else inside the Mercedes. I could smell the leather seats. This car was new.
“Fuck you and your goddamn sandwich,” I told her. I heaved the sandwich away from the car, making sure that it would land on my embankment. “Now where’s the money, lady?” I held out my palm and waited for the money that I knew wasn’t coming.
“Sorry, buddy, but I won’t be the one to support your habits.”
“What habits, lady? Listen, I’m trying to get a bus ticket back home to Richmond.”
“I know you’ll just spend it on booze and drugs.”
“No way, lady. I’m just trying to get back home to my nephew in Richmond.”
The car behind the woman began honking. The light had turned green. “I’m sorry, I just can’t support your lifestyle.” She stepped on the accelerator and made a left under the underpass. I smiled and looked up at my embankment to the sandwich in the plastic bag.
I waited for a few minutes and put my sign on the ground and set a rock on it, so it wouldn’t blow away. I took the Ziploc freezer bag out of my jacket pocket and put my book back in it, making sure that the bag was sealed. I walked back to my embankment and grabbed the sandwich on my way up to the top of the underpass.
The sandwich was whole wheat and turkey. My favorite. I sat and ate the sandwich: savoring it. When I was done, I could feel the blood rush out of my head to help the digestion of my fair-weather brunch. Drowsiness began to set in, but I didn’t yawn. I stuck my hands in my pockets and curled up in the shadow of the underpass for a mid-morning nap.
* * *
I awoke in sweats. The sun was beating down and it had grown too warm for my jacket.
I went through my waking routine (without yawning) and removed my jacket and tied it around my waist. I made my way down my embankment to my begging spot, not forgetting to bring my book. My sign was waiting for me where I left it. I lifted the rock from the sign and removed my book from the plastic bag, replacing the sign with the bag under the rock.
Assuming my normal position, book narrowly opened in one hand, sign in the other, I read and waited. It must have been between the post-school crowd—mothers returning home with their children—and rush hour.
I stood and read there for what must have been about an hour, having received two “get-a-jobs” and a “get-a-life-asshole.” Rush hour was now in full swing and the sun was quickly descending when I heard a man’s voice: “Excuse me, sir.”
Generally, the excuse-me-sir-ers of the world wanted directions. I looked up and to my surprise saw a few crisp bills hanging out the cracked window of a silver Toyota Camry. I was a little disappointed. I would have much preferred another turkey sandwich. Money meant that I would have to walk the two blocks to the McDonalds down the street. Oh well, at least it would be a warm meal before going to sleep.
As I approached the car, the cash slipped back inside the car and the window rolled down all the way to reveal a brown-haired man in wireframe glasses. He was wearing a white short-sleeved collared shirt with an argyle sweater vest. Goddamn excuse-me-sir bastard wanted directions after all.
“Excuse me, sir, but how much would you take for that book you are reading?” the man asked.
“Not for sale, pal.”
“No, seriously, I will give you a hundred bucks for it.”
“Get lost, pal. Not for sale. Seriously.”
The man began thumbing through the cash in his wallet. “Wait. Let’s see here.” Cars behind the man started honking, indicating the change of the traffic light. “Hold your horses,” the man yelled to the car behind him. “I have three hundred thirty seven dollars. You can have all of it for that book. Get yourself a room for a few nights. Get cleaned up and…”
“Listen, asswipe,” I interrupted, “what don’t you fucking understand about not for sale? That sweater vest cutting off the circulation to your brain?”
“Hey, man. I’m trying to do you a favor.” The flurry of honks grew louder and more urgent.
“Favor? Fuck your favor.”
“Listen. I don’t know if you know what you have there. I run a rare books shop on Lincoln Road. I just want…”
“Fuck off.” I began walking the wrong way down the access road, so that he couldn’t follow. I heard him yell after me before finally hearing the squealing of tires. I peaked over my shoulder to see the Camry speeding through an all-but-expired yellow light, forcing the next car to and wait through another light.
Fucking inconsiderate asshole. The book was the only thing. Didn’t he understand that? If I had wanted money, I would have sold the thing long ago. The book was my cross-country companion. The only thing in the world that I had to take care of or worry about.
I went to sleep hungry that night. I slept with one eye open and with the book, secure in its Ziploc bag, tucked into the front of my pants, underneath my shirt and jacket.
* * *
I had slept like shit. I kept having a recurring dream where I opened up my book, but all the pages were grotesque versions of one hundred dollar bills. A morose Ben Franklin was animated on the page. He kept saying, “Green green goblins,” over and over.
I tried to shake off the feelings that the dream and the bad night of sleep had left me with while I made my way down to my intersection. I leaned down to pick up my sign, which I had dropped on the ground without putting the rock on it. It was damn lucky the wind hadn’t blown overnight.
From the edge of my vision, I noticed someone getting out of their car in the motel parking lot on the corner. I turned my glance to the car. Fuck. It was the silver Camry. The excuse-me-sir jackass was on his way over to my concrete island with its traffic light palm tree. My paradise.
I considered running, but I was hungry and weak. I didn’t want to leave my post. I would just decline the man again and then try and get something to eat.
“Hello there again, sir,” the man called as he crossed during the red light at a slight jog. He arrived on my island. “I’m sorry about yesterday. That money I was offering you is an insult for what you’ve got there. My name is Raymond.” He held out his hand to shake.
Ignoring the hand I responded, “You can call me, Sal.”
He paused for a moment, not knowing what to do with his extended hand. He opted to put it in his pocket. “Pleasure to meet you, Sal. You have quite a treasure there. You do still have the book, right.”
I knocked on my abdomen so the man could hear the hardcover still concealed in the front of my pants.
“Good. Great. Can I see it?”
“Hell no.”
His eyes searched for the words. “Ehhh. I would probably say the same thing if it were my book. In fact, I have often said such things when people ask to see my rare books. Anyhow, I went by the bank this morning. I can make you a much more lucrative offer. I can offer you…”
“Not interested,” I interrupted. I tried not to make eye contact with the man, Raymond. I held up my sign and tried to look only at the cars.
“Listen. I want to offer you three thousand dollars. It’s a first edition. One I have been searching for a long time. Especially one in as good condition as that one,” he said pointing to my abdomen. “I won’t even be selling it or anything. It’s for my private collection. It’s not something that I would even consider trying to turn a profit on. I have a passion for books. That’s why I opened up my book shop in the first place.”
“Not for sale,” I said even-toned. I couldn’t help but make momentary eye contact with Raymond. Surrender wasn’t yet present in his face.
“Well, listen. I can give you five thousand, plus the three hundred thirty seven that I had on me last night. It’s all the money I have on me. More than the list price, even. Please, I have never seen a first edition in that good of a condition.”
“Seriously. Not…for…sale, Raymond.” My voice was beginning to lose its even keel.
Raymond guffawed. “Well, why the hell not? I mean, why on earth do you need it? You could get started with a few months lease on an apartment. Get cleaned up. Even get a job.”
“I don’t want a fucking apartment or a job,” I was looking straight into Raymond’s eyes now, burning my swelling anger into his skull.
“Why the hell do you need the book? Why won’t you sell it to me? I don’t care what you do with the money. Spend it all on booze and drugs, for all I care.”
“I don’t do that shit, asshole.”
“Then why the hell won’t you sell me the book?”
I took a deep breath. It was none of this guy’s damn business why I wanted my book, but I could see in Raymond’s face that he wouldn’t relent until he had an answer, so I would give him the only answer I had—the truth. “Because it’s the only thing that I have from my old life, and quite frankly, it’s the only thing I wanted.”
The man glance shifted from my face to my abdomen, then back up to my face again. He was perplexed. “But…”
“Listen. Not for sale.” I chucked my cardboard sign at Raymond and started to walk away.
I could hear him calling “Sal! Sal!” as I walked the wrong way in the gutter of the access road. I didn’t turn around.
* * *
At dusk I was walking barefoot on the beach—my feet tired and my stomach grumbling. The sand was cool and felt damp against my feet.
“Green green goblins,” I muttered under my breath over and over. I was holding my book in my left hand as I walked. I had removed it from the Ziploc and discarded the
I kept walking. I stared down and kept repeating the phrase from my nightmare. “Green green goblins.”
I noticed the edge of a blue piece of paper or cardboard protruding from the sand. I stopped and reached down into the sand and removed the object from the sand. It was a matchbook. I blew the sand off of it and read the back. “Happy’s” it read. There was an address and phone number in Miami underneath. I opened up the matchbook and there was one match left. I closed the matchbook.
I sat down on the cool sand, facing the ocean, the sun setting behind my back. I flipped through my book until I was in the middle and set the book down on the sand. The book sat there staring back at me.
“Green green goblins,” I muttered.
I opened the matchbook and struck the match. I stared at the match turning from an incandescent blue to orange. I held the match to the corner of one of the open pages of the book. It caught fire and I discarded the match. I watch the fire spread over the words, shriveling and erasing them. The fire spread to the other open half of the book.
“Green green goblins,” I whispered one last time.
I sat until the crackling of the fire died out. Before me was nothing more than a pile of ashes and a few pieces of shriveled cardboard from the hardcover. I sat exhausted and listened to the soothing sounds of the ocean, not muttering, not whispering. I yawned.
Wednesday, February 18, 2009
Review of All the Pretty Horses by Cormac McCarthy
One thing that I really like that McCarthy does in both novels is the blurring of the lines between right and wrong. While this is a Modernist idea and has been well-handled by writers the likes of Hemingway and Faulkner, McCarthy seems to go a step further and create situations for the characters where committing moral atrocities falls into the gray area. In All the Pretty Horses, McCarthy leaves the reader thinking about when it is justified to kill and steal from others. In fact, an appearance of a judge at the end of the novel justifies some of the actions of John Grady Cole. In fact, the judge seems to write off the wrongdoings of Cole by stating that there were no other choices for Cole in the situations that the protagonist has lived through.
Desolation also seems to be a theme in McCarthy works (also noting the desolation found in the film version of No Country for Old Men). The part of West Texas and the deserts of Mexico in which the story takes place are almost a post-apocalyptic world-- the same world that we see in The Road. The landscape in All the Pretty Horses is a reflection of the characters' (John Grady and Rawlins) emotional state. Their lives have become empty, pointless, dry, and depressing. The only moment in the book when John Grady Cole exists for any amount of time as acceptable in a civilization is when he is working on the hacienda, but the hacienda even rejects Cole in the end, and the reader is almost positive that Cole will continue searching for his place in the world fruitlessly.
I also noticed that McCarthy creates a surrogate family of sorts for the characters of Cole, Rawlins, and Blevins. The three boys (men) all seem to have drawn the same lot in life. These characters can understand one another. Rawlins comes across as a somewhat flat character without much of a background story, and it could be argued that he ultimately rejects his role as an outsider. In the end it seems that he will pursue a career in something in which he can make some money. Cole and Blevins accept their role as outsiders, to each of their detriment. This acceptance also explains why Cole is able to accept Blevins and Rawlins has a hard time doing the same.
As I have come to expect in all McCarthy novels, there is a lot of metaphorical language. One moment in the book that struck me especially strongly was toward the end of the novel when John Grady Cole encounters a wild pack of dogs. One of the dogs falls down and the other dogs begin to pounce on the dog; however, the dog gets up and keeps on going. Cole has also metaphorically fallen down. I immediately knew that the fallen dog represented Cole and he would continue on.
The book is also highlighted by a very unique and interesting love story between Cole, a poor sixteen year old destined for nothing more than a life of hard labor and Alejandra, the daughter of the hacendado who is well-educated and well-cultured. The love story flips a lot of cliches on their head when it comes to class. Alejandra, a Mexican by birth, would most likely be considered poor by American standards. However, the American male is placed under her. Instead of the woman trying to elevate herself to a certain class, as is so often the case in stories, it is the male seeking the female who is considered above him by the society he has entered. All the Pretty Horses paints a complex and unusual social picture.
I would recommend this book to literary friends of mine. I found the book very engaging, but could definitely understand someone who could be bored very easily. The book is anything but action packed, and if you can't handle a sense of desolation, I wouldn't recommend it. The novel definitely took me into the main character of Cole, someone who I have absolutely nothing in common with as far as my interests and station in life. I felt Cole's desolation. McCarthy is quickly becoming one of my contemporary favorites.
Wednesday, February 4, 2009
Review of Stardust by Neil Gaiman
The first thing that Gaiman impressed upon me in Stardust is how adept he is at creating a world out of nothing. Though the book is under three hundred pages, the author has no problem creating the world of Faerie, where ships can fly and one can walk on clouds and a candle can act as a teleportation device and where stars are girls. My image of Faerie was somewhat tainted by the film adaptation of the book, but it gave me a starting place. In all reality, the book is far more imaginative and fantastic than the film ever dared.
One major theme that Gaiman plays with is that of imagination and consciousness. The wall in the city of Wall is what separates imagination and reality or consciousness and sub-consciousness. The book could be read as completely taking place in the imagination, but the omniscient narrator does not treat it as such, and often treats the unbelievable events that take place in a book as commonplace and certainly nothing out of the ordinary. Tristran has the most unique perspective in the book, being a child of both worlds. His journey into Faerie marks the beginning of his manhood. Tristran certainly meets the requirements for an epic hero in his trial by fire.
One thing that I now don't particularly like about the film version is the treatment of the seven brothers. In the movie, the brothers serve no purpose other than comic relief, and in Primus' case a vehicle for the plot. Not to say that the brothers are not humorous, but Gaiman treats the brothers with the seriousness that they deserve. They are seeking to become rulers of a kingdom in earnest. They are not the oafs that are portrayed in the film. Septimus, in particular, is cunning and persistent. The brothers also really motivate the plot in the novel.
As in every fantasy novel of this nature, all details, no matter how small, are integral to the plot. I also thought it was really interesting how Gaiman manages to tie all of Tristran's loose ends up, without making the ending seem trite. This is probably because Yvaine's eternal fate is a little less certain and a little less upbeat. The conclusion of the novel is exactly what it needs to be. It doesn't drag on for ages as so many conclusions in fantasy novels do, but gives the reader the necessary information. The concentration of the story is on the journey itself, and doesn't hinder itself with things like lore and history.
I would recommend this novel for anyone who enjoys a fantasy novel, male or female, teen or adult. It is an easy and enjoyable read.
