Eleanor & Park by Rainbow RowellMy rating: 3 of 5 stars
I really wanted to give the book a 3.5. Goodreads should really implement a decimal point system. I think I wanted to like the book more than I did. It was fairly built up for me by my wife.
Park is certainly a character that I would aspire to be like in real life, but on paper, he falls flat. I don't think Park ever really gets Eleanor. I don't think that he ever truly understand the dire straits that she comes from. He doesn't understand her present or her past, and he never really pushes hard enough to understand. He is a naturally good-hearted person, but often seems selfish. He might be doing the right thing, but it often seems like he is doing it for the wrong reason He just doesn't go through the kind of change that this experience, this relationship, should have caused. I think my wife thought I would love the book because I am similar to Park. We certainly have common ground: loads of it, but I guess, like the character, I am a little boring. Who wants to read about their own life?
Eleanor redeemed the book. I liked when we were in her limited third person perspective, which does bring up a point about perspective: I am entirely unsure why this book is told from two third-person limited perspectives. It would make more sense to me to have it take place from two first-person ones. The narrator pretty much lets the reader into the thoughts of both characters. I actually think that the characters telling their own story would have been more interesting and added a certain illogic to their thoughts. Because it was in third person, I often had trouble relating to the thoughts of the characters that were being revealed by an unnecessary third party. While these are certainly illogical, shy, confused teenagers, adding that third-person just separates me from characters I want to feel closer to.
As I was saying, Eleanor is the dynamic, truly different character. Park certainly believes that he marches to the beat of his own drummer, but Eleanor has her own percussion section (yeah, I stole that from somewhere). Her story is far more captivating: her slow reveals to her atrocious home situation and recent exile. There is so much more emotional charge to the characters surrounding her: I hated her stepdad certainly, but I felt almost an equal disdain for her helpless mother.
The end of the book is redeeming in many ways. (view spoiler)
Anyhow, it was a good YA book, but I don't believe it will become a stalwart standard of the genre. ["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>
View all my reviews


